normative

Carroll's eternalist justification for one-boxing

Carroll justifies one-boxing in Newcomb's paradox by reasoning that there are two pre-existing possible worlds (one with a million dollars in the opaque box, one without) and that although his choice does not change which world he is in, the predicting being knows which world he is in and is reliably telling him, so he rationally chooses to inhabit the world where he takes one box and gets a million dollars.

normativepending

Speaker

Sean Carroll

Evidence Quote

“this magical being, who is the game show host, does know which possible world I'm in and is telling me. And so I'm gonna believe the magical being who knows more about the set of possible worlds, and I'm gonna pick living in the world where I get a million dollars”

Source

244 | Katie Elliott on Metaphysics, Chance, and Explanation— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:22:03 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...