factual

Stranger improves groups who don't appreciate it

In controlled murder-mystery experiments where all members had identical information, groups of three friends plus a stranger significantly outperformed groups of four friends because members felt compelled to justify their reasoning to the stranger—yet these higher-performing groups didn't realize they did better, didn't think they had solved it, and didn't enjoy the experience.

factualpending

Speaker

Tim Harford

Evidence Quote

“unambiguously that improves the problem-solving performance of the group; and unambiguously the group completely fails to appreciate this.”

Source

Tim Harford on the Virtues of Disorder and Messy— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:25:48 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...