normative

Carroll: only causal or emergent consciousness is respectable

Carroll argues there are two respectable options for consciousness: modify the laws of physics so mental aspects have genuine causal influence (hard, high barrier, but respectable), or treat consciousness as an emergent property of ordinary physical behavior; the intermediate panpsychist view—mental aspects that are crucially important yet have zero causal influence—he does not even consider respectable.

normativepending

Speaker

Sean Carroll

Evidence Quote

“this idea that mental aspects are there and somehow utterly important yet have zero causal influence, that's what I said, I don't even quite consider to be respectable”

Source

149 | Lee Smolin on Time, Philosophy, and the Nature of Reality— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:33:28 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...