normative
A Coherent Caligula Cannot Be Refuted by Logic
Because moral systems are constructed from preferences rather than derived from objective facts, a person with monstrous but internally coherent moral impulses (Sharon Street's 'coherent Caligula') is not making any logical or scientific mistake; we cannot argue them out of it by reason, and the only recourse is to stop them from causing harm, which is in fact what we actually do.
normativepending
Speaker
Sean CarrollEvidence Quote
“you can't argue with them that they are wrong on the basis of logic, or science or reason”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:17:41 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...