causal
Supercollider thought experiment favors anti-Humeanism
Imagine a unique experiment that, under theory A succeeds but under theory B triggers a new Big Bang; an anti-Humean treats it as a fact which laws are correct so we should cautiously avoid risk, while a strict Humean—who holds laws are summaries of what actually happens—would find that if the experiment is never run, the unique conditions never occur, leaving it indeterminate which laws are correct, which conflicts with how we actually reason.
causalpending
Speaker
Ned HallEvidence Quote
“If we don't do the experiment, then it's simply indeterminate whether the laws are the A laws or the B laws. But that's not the way we would actually think about this.”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:19:13 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...