normative

Independent Questions Carve Nature at Joints

When a question turns out to be independent of ZFC, you have asked exactly the right question because you have found a cleavage in mathematical reality—worlds where it is true and worlds where it is false—which is to be celebrated rather than lamented as a failure.

normativepending

Speaker

Joel David Hamkins

Evidence Quote

“when you ask a question that turns out to be independent, then you asked exactly the right question because this is the one... It's carving nature at its joints. You're adjudicating the nature of set theoretic reality by finding these two realms.”

Source

Joel David Hamkins— Lex Fridman Podcast
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:33:58 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...