factual

Free will disagreements are semantic yet emergence is real

Carroll apparently characterized disagreements about free will as largely semantic in a previous AMA, while arguing in the same episode that emergent phenomena are genuinely real, and seemed to endorse free will emerging from agency in the Christian List episode. These positions look contradictory.

factualpending

Speaker

Alen

Evidence Quote

“In the previous AMA you characterized disagreements about free will as largely semantic, despite arguing just minutes earlier in the same episode that emergent phenomena are genuinely real.”

Source

Aak Me Anything | November 2026— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 11/17/2026, 6:32:41 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...