definition

Science is a group-level argument over agreed tests

Science is fundamentally a group-level process: not just running experiments but arguing in a seminar room where disagreements are settled not by seniority, charisma, or PowerPoint but by agreeing in advance on tests whose outcomes will distinguish competing claims, then running them and admitting who was right; humans are bad at evaluating their own ideas but good at evaluating others', so the group is the engine that gets chronically overconfident individuals closer to reality.

definitionpending

Speaker

Andrew McAfee

Evidence Quote

“Science is an eternal argument governed by a ground rule... we are not going to determine A versus B by seniority, or charisma, or PowerPoint... Let's nail that down in advance.”

Source

Andrew McAfee on the Geek Way— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:15:44 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...