causal

Early Universe Had Low Gravitational Entropy

The cosmic microwave background's near-perfect Planck (black body) spectrum indicates the early matter and radiation were already at maximum entropy, which seems paradoxical given the second law; the resolution is that the relevant low entropy of the early universe lay specifically in gravitational degrees of freedom—the universe was extraordinarily uniform (smooth) so gravity had nowhere clumped, and entropy then rose as matter clumped into stars and especially black holes whose entropy is stupendous.

causalpending

Speaker

Roger Penrose

Evidence Quote

“Now those stars will tend to clump because of their gravitation attraction, and eventually become black holes and as they do this, the entropy goes shooting up. Particularly with the black holes, because as we know from Bekenstein and Hawking, the entropy is absolutely enormous. So that represents an increase in entropy. So you have these two things about the early universe, one is the Planck spectrum... but the other feature about it is that it's uniform, and that as far as gravity is concerned, is very low entropy.”

Source

28 | Roger Penrose on Spacetime, Consciousness, and the Universe— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:23:12 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...