causal

The intentional stance explains resistance to emergence

We resist bottom-up explanations because of Dennett's 'intentional stance': a reflex assumption that things were designed, created, or planned rather than emergent—we attribute agency and intentionality even to inanimate objects—probably because in the Stone Age it was safer to assume a thrown stone had a thrower; the modern version is the belief that politicians can fix any problem.

causalpending

Speaker

Matt Ridley

Evidence Quote

“it's better to err in that direction than in the opposite direction back in the Pleistocene Stone Age. If you get hit on the back of the head by a stone... is not necessarily as sensible as to turn around and say, 'Who threw that stone?'... the modern version of the intentional stance is to have a sort of belief that politicians can fix any problem.”

Source

Matt Ridley on the Evolution of Everything— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:25:43 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...