causal

Group Selection Arguments Usually Fail

Group selection arguments for traits like maintaining crazy ideas in a population should be treated skeptically without hard quantitative backing, because even if a mixed group outperforms a uniform group, within the mixed group the individuals with reasonable ideas do better, so the genes for crazy ideas are selected away.

causalpending

Speaker

Carl Bergstrom

Evidence Quote

“As an evolutionary biologist, I tend to be pretty skeptical of group selection arguments without really, really hard quantitative backing, because they just typically don't go through”

Source

108 | Carl Bergstrom on Information, Disinformation, and Bullshit— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:22:15 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...