normative
Heuristics for judging fringe claims honestly
To stay honest while not evaluating every claim, use outside-view criteria: would you check out an equally implausible but more desirable theory; do smart, reasonable people you trust find it promising; and do you get angry when anyone takes it seriously—the last being a sign your stated reason of 'not worth my time' is actually motivated.
normativepending
Speaker
Julia GalefEvidence Quote
“if some smart and reasonable people whose judgment I trust in other ways think that this claim is at least promising... then if I then still am reluctant to even consider the possibility... then that seems a little suspicious to me”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:29:03 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...