Nobody has a bigger romance about science than the critics of medical science. They think that if it's called science it must have all the answers, for example that it isn't science unless reported symptoms can be traced to an underlying organic cause. We can't do that for most symptoms, but that doesn't mean we shouldn't treat them or that treatment is unscientific; it is a best guess. Greenberg in particular expects too much of science, especially medical science dealing with minds.

normativepending

Speaker

Louis Menand

Evidence Quote

“it's just making the best guess about whether this thing is a disorder that can be treated by medication or not”

Source

Louis Menand on Psychiatry 05/31/2010— EconTalk
Created: 10/29/2026, 7:34:04 PM

Your notes

Loading notes...