factual

Intransitivity of support undermines confirmation

Support is intransitive: evidence that Linda is a banker supports 'banker and feminist,' which logically implies 'feminist,' yet being a banker is itself no support (even counter-support) for being a feminist. So increasing credence in a theory does not generally increase credence in its consequences—only rarely, in uninteresting cases.

factualpending

Speaker

David Deutsch

Evidence Quote

“Being a banker supports being a banker and a feminist, being a banker and a feminist supports, because it implies being a feminist. So A implies B, sorry, A supports B, B supports C, but A countersupports C.”

Source

253 | David Deutsch on Science, Complexity, and Explanation— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:24:02 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...