causal

Corporate argument beats serial academic peer review

Academic peer review is broken partly because it resembles thinking alone—papers are reviewed by people who already agree or lack incentives to scrutinize, and disagreement plays out seriatim through separate published counter-papers—whereas corporate decision-making lets people defend ideas synchronously in a facilitated conversation around a table, which produces better outcomes than serial debate.

causalpending

Speaker

Russ Roberts

Evidence Quote

“the formal process of science through academic journals is a debate conducted seriatim--meaning you take turns... In the kind of work that you're talking about in your book, people have to defend their ideas in a conversation, not a debate.”

Source

Andrew McAfee on the Geek Way— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:15:44 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...