normative

Neuro-Centric Critique of Embodied Cognition

While sympathetic to embodied cognition's emphasis on body-environment interaction, Barwich is critical of strong versions (e.g. Alva Noë's 'we perceive outside the brain'), holding a neuro-centric position aligned with Patricia Churchland: the body matters and must be understood to understand the brain, but the brain remains the central processing organ with causal primacy, as clinical cases (Oliver Sacks) of things going wrong demonstrate.

normativepending

Speaker

Ann-Sophie Barwich

Evidence Quote

“I don't think that means something in the sense of, "Oh, well, we perceive outside the brain," in terms of that there's any form of causal primacy of a process.”

Source

105 | Ann-Sophie Barwich on the Science and Philosophy of Smell— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:06:35 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...