normative
Convergence Must Be Parsed by Underlying Cause
Convergence should not be treated as a monolithic, homogeneous phenomenon that simply refutes Gould; instead one must examine the underlying causes of each repetition, because some convergences genuinely cut against contingency while others do not, so the data set must be carefully parsed before drawing grand conclusions about a cosmic biology.
normativepending
Speaker
Rachell PowellEvidence Quote
“certain kinds of repetitions start to look like, well, maybe these really do fly in the face of of a Gouldian contingency theory, whereas other kinds of repetitions don't. So I think we need to really be careful in parsing that data set”
Source
342 | Rachell Powell on Evolutionary Convergence, Morality, and Mind— Sean Carroll's MindscapeCreated: 6/13/2026, 12:29:32 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...