causal

Good And Evil Are Not Fungible Dirt

Yudkowsky's claim that enough trivial harms (e.g., a googolplex of hiccups) must outweigh a single horrific harm (a shark attack) is wrong because it treats good and evil as undifferentiated, tradable mounds of dirt; in reality there are qualitative differences between types of goods and evils—no number of stubbed toes adds up to a Holocaust, and no number of warm socks adds up to saving a life—so they are not commensurable or fungible.

causalpending

Speaker

Erik Hoel

Evidence Quote

“there's something really deeply wrong with viewing good and evil as essentially big mounds of tradable dirt. They're not tradable. It's not fungible in the way that they want it to be.”

Source

Erik Hoel on Effective Altruism, Utilitarianism, and the Repugnant Conclusion— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:17:40 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...