causal

Act-state dependence breaks decision theory

Transformative choices violate the act-state independence axiom because the act of undergoing the experience changes who you are, so the state (your post-choice self and its satisfaction) is dependent on the act rather than independent of it; you cannot tell whether your future satisfaction reflects a pre-existing preference being realized or your preferences simply being replaced, leaving no principled way to decide which self should take priority.

causalpending

Speaker

L.A. Paul

Evidence Quote

“Which self matters? The self making the decision, or the self that would result? If they conflict, and there's no meta principle to resolve it, like the selves don't agree on what the ultimate correct decision should be, then you don't have a decision rule that you can use.”

Source

L.A. Paul on Vampires, Life Choices, and Transformation— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:24:09 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...