factual

Frequencies vs probabilities in particular cases

Bayes' theorem is legitimately useful for particular (not general) questions—like a doctor estimating dengue fever from travel history—but this is really reasoning about finite frequencies approximated as probabilities, used because of an absence of explanation rather than a genuine credence; such methods cannot decide between general theories because the relevant set of individuals would be infinite.

factualpending

Speaker

David Deutsch

Evidence Quote

“it's sometimes a good approximation to approximate frequencies by probabilities, or rather by numbers that obey the probability calculus. And they don't increase our knowledge.”

Source

253 | David Deutsch on Science, Complexity, and Explanation— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:24:02 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...