factual

Ming Exam Performance Was Independent of Family Background

The Chinese civil service examination was genuinely meritocratic in a narrow sense: data from the Ming Dynasty show family background did not affect candidates' performance—remarkable compared to the SAT today which still correlates with background—achieved through state subsidies, well-administered protocols, and a double-anonymization system (examiner and examinee unknown to each other, with scribes recopying papers to hide handwriting).

factualpending

Speaker

Yasheng Huang

Evidence Quote

“Anonymization — China invented a double anonymization system. The examiner didn’t know who the examinee was; the examinee didn’t know who the examiner was.”

Source

Yasheng Huang— Conversations with Tyler
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:34:49 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...