factual

Clerical rule is a heretical innovation in Shi'ism

Direct clerical rule, on which the Islamic Republic is founded, is a brand-new and frankly heretical idea that Khomeini invented out of whole cloth—there is no precedent in 1,400 years of Shi'a thought for it—and it is not a popular theology among Shi'as, so while the entrenched upper-echelon clerics defend it, younger and mid-level clerics harbor enormous frustration with and even rejection of the theology behind clerical rule.

factualpending

Speaker

Reza Aslan

Evidence Quote

“there is an enormous amount of frustration, and I would even say rejection of the theology behind clerical rule.”

Source

Reza Aslan— Conversations with Tyler
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:27:37 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...