normative

Journals' Refusal to Publish Replications Lets Wrong Results Stand

The problem lies with journals that won't publish replications: editors don't want to devote ten pages to an error that doesn't invalidate a whole paper, and young scholars are discouraged because replication annoys people, builds no reputation, and is hard to place. The result is that wrong results stay published and people keep believing them; a fix would be short, two-page replication studies attached to every paper, published whether or not the result replicates.

normativepending

Speaker

Betsey Stevenson

Evidence Quote

“And the result of that is bad results stay. Wrong results stay published and people keep thinking wrong results are right.”

Source

Betsey Stevenson and Justin Wolfers on Happiness, Growth, and the Reinhart-Rogoff Controversy— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:04:40 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...