China and Russia cannot successfully operate as maritime powers because neither possesses Mahan's six prerequisites: neither has defensive moats (both are surrounded by numerous hostile or potentially hostile neighbors), neither has reliable sea access (both surrounded by narrow, island-cluttered coastal seas controlled by neighboring states), Russia lacks dense coastal population and a commerce-driven economy, and neither has stable government institutions (lacking regular transparent transfers of executive power).
causalpending
Speaker
Dr. Sarah Cimbala PayneEvidence Quote
“if you look at China and Russia Today neither one of them has a full list of six... they each have more neighbors than any other two countries on the planet... neither one has reliable access by sea because they're all surrounded by um narrow Island cluttered uh Coastal seas”
Source
NWC 2025 INS Lecture - Dr. Sarah Paine: Geopolitics, Cold War Lessons and the Way Forward— U.S. Naval War CollegeCreated: 8/11/2026, 7:36:57 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...