normative
Scientists should critique their own ideas
Good theoretical scientists should be their own ideas' biggest critics rather than biggest advocates; those who claim advocacy is optimal because a free market of ideas will sort things out are likely rationalizing the pleasure of advocacy, and in practice—especially in social science where experiments rarely settle questions—the advocacy model fails to weed out true from false ideas because few people vet the arguments.
normativepending
Speaker
Julia GalefEvidence Quote
“ideas get... They get attention and they get publications and they get TED Talks and articles, without all that much vetting of whether they're really sound”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:29:03 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...