definition

Two Definitions Of Merit: Earned Versus Instrumental

The word 'merit' has two distinct meanings that get confused in genetics discourse: merit as morally earned and deserved (like a merit badge), versus merit as purely instrumental (like hiring a pilot for their ability to fly a plane based on morally arbitrary traits like correctable vision); conflating these underlies much confusion about genetics.

definitionpending

Speaker

Paige Harden

Evidence Quote

“These are morally arbitrary human functionings, and yet we do think that we should hire pilots on their merits, which is their ability to fly a plane. I think what gets so lost in our discourse about this is people kind of shuffling back and forth between these two definitions.”

Source

165 | Kathryn Paige Harden on Genetics, Luck, and Fairness— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:23:25 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...