factual

Moral disagreement does not refute objective ethics

The existence of intractable moral disagreement should not lead us to abandon objective ethical truth, because just as a flat-earther can maintain internal consistency by rejecting any dislodging premise without that making their view legitimate, ethical rationality involves more than mere consistency with evidence; our inability to persuade someone is dialectical inefficacy, not proof there is no fact of the matter.

factualpending

Speaker

Kieran Setiya

Evidence Quote

“dialectical efficacy like being able to actually persuade people is one thing but the fact that you can't persuade someone who's a conspiracy theorist or committed flat earther and we'll say anything it takes to to avoid internal inconsistency that shouldn't make us think that that's a legitimate view it's still an unjustified response to the evidence”

Source

295 - Philosophy And The Good Life— Making Sense with Sam Harris
Created: 6/14/2026, 2:54:42 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...