causal
Zombie argument undercuts itself on self-knowledge
If a physical zombie acts exactly like a conscious person, then when asked whether it is conscious it sincerely answers yes and denies lying, so it honestly believes it is conscious just as we do; therefore none of us could know we are not zombies, which Carroll wields as the best argument against views that treat consciousness as something over and above behavior.
causalpending
Speaker
Sean CarrollEvidence Quote
“if it acts exactly the same, that includes when you ask it, 'Do you have consciousness or are you experiencing things?' It says, 'Yes.' ... So clearly it honestly thinks it's conscious but it's not by hypothesis.”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:10:44 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...