factual

Commitment must be stipulated, not read off quantifiers

Quine's criterion fails on both fronts: natural language does not commit you merely by saying 'there are' (as the Greek gods example shows), and a formalism only commits you to what you stipulate, since neither bound variables nor a semantic interpretation automatically 'yells out' commitment.

factualpending

Speaker

Jody Azzouni

Evidence Quote

“there's no argument that anyone has that we have to read any of the languages we use, natural language or formalisms, mathematic, etcetera, in a way that requires us, by virtue of 'there are' followed by noun phrase, has to commit us.”

Source

178 | Jody Azzouni on What Is and Isn't Real— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:09:01 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...