causal
Civil service is a closed caste, not meritocratic
The 1850s reform replaced an aristocratic patronage system (which was corrupt but faster and more efficient in crises) with a supposedly meritocratic permanent civil service that over time became a closed caste promoting almost 100% internally, thereby excluding nearly 100% of the world's most talented people and producing paralysis when crises hit.
causalpending
Speaker
Dominic CummingsEvidence Quote
“this supposedly meritocratic system ends up actually just being a closed caste. It's not actually meritocratic. It's a system that promotes practically 100% internally and is therefore, by definition, closed to approximately 100% of the world's most talented people.”
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:19:39 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...