causal
Stimulus Was Non-Exogenous, Not An Experiment
The $800 billion stimulus was not a natural experiment because it was not randomly decided—Obama enacted it for a reason responding to economic conditions, and the state-to-state variations are also non-random and depend on assumptions about national-level effects—so its inconclusive aftermath cannot prove anything, unlike a randomized lottery study which ranks much higher on the scale of convincing identification.
causalpending
Speaker
Noah SmithEvidence Quote
“It's not as if Obama just woke up one day and some quantum state flipped in his brain and said, 'Let's do an $800 billion dollar stimulus' and then it happened. It wasn't like that. There was a reason why it happened”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:23:15 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...