Secret societies are hard to sustain because they must both keep and reveal secrets: people recruited under one narrative who are later told 'that was fake, here's the real plan' may be true believers in the original story, so the society fails by recruiting people it then turns out were the wrong fit — the inverse of what happened with early al-Qaeda, where associates thought bin Laden was a loser to mooch off until he organized real attacks.

causalpending

Speaker

Byrne Hobart

Evidence Quote

“a lot of the people who worked with bin laden in the 90s thought he was a loser but that he had money and so they were sort of scamming him”

Source

Byrne Hobart - Optionality, Stagnation, and Secret Societies— Dwarkesh Patel
Created: 6/13/2026, 7:01:47 PM

Your notes

Loading notes...