normative
Aid May Be Restitution, Not Charity
The shallow pond experiment is ahistorical—it ignores how people got into the pond; if imperialism or colonialism is one cause among many of present poverty, then handing money over is not charity but more like giving back a bicycle you stole twenty years ago, and Parfit held that money may not be truly ours either because it was stolen or because we merely got lucky being born in a wealthy country, so we should not see it as ours to give or withhold as we choose.
normativepending
Speaker
David EdmondsEvidence Quote
“in both cases parfitt certainly believed that we shouldn't see this money as as it were ours to give or not to give as we chose”
Created: 6/14/2026, 2:04:20 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...