factual

Trolley Intuitions Flip Between Switch and Push

Across cultures, genders, and education levels, roughly 95% of people think you should flip a switch to divert a train and kill one to save five, but the same proportion think you should not push a man off a footbridge to stop the train and save five, even though the body count (one dies, five saved) is identical—posing a puzzle for any account that looks only at consequences.

factualpending

Speaker

David Edmonds

Evidence Quote

“almost everybody thinks that in the first case it is right to turn the train and in the second case it's wrong to push the fat man or the man with a heavy rucksack and so the puzzle in this thought experiment is to explain why because in both cases you are saving five lives at the cost of one”

Source

448 - The Philosophy Of Good And Evil— Making Sense with Sam Harris
Created: 6/14/2026, 2:04:20 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...