factual

One person one vote is recent and may be insufficient

The principle 'one person, one vote' is very new—entering Supreme Court jurisprudence around 1963 and traced through John Lewis to the ANC and Nelson Mandela in South Africa—and we should ask whether it is even democratic, since votes are unequally weighted (Senate, Electoral College, districting) and felons are disenfranchised; we could push to 'one person, one equally weighted vote,' or 'one person, three votes' via ranked-choice, or even 'one person, no vote' via sortition.

factualpending

Speaker

Astra Taylor

Evidence Quote

“here we are, this beautiful phrase, this beautiful ideal comes from South Africa through the civil rights movement, and now we take it for granted. Like, 'Oh, yeah, one person one vote, that just makes sense.' Well, no, it's really new.”

Source

57 | Astra Taylor on the Promise and Challenge of Democracy— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:11:10 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...