causal

Grief responds to reasons like other emotions

Grief is a rational response to the reason of loss, just as anger responds to insult and fear to danger; but because the object of grief (that a loved one is dead) never changes, there is no information in the object that tells us how long to grieve, creating a genuine puzzle about how it can ever become rational to stop grieving.

causalpending

Speaker

Kieran Setiya

Evidence Quote

“if the reason for grief is just that my loved one is dead that's not going to change i mean the reason that just stays the same and it stays the same forever so now we face the question the puzzle is less why should we grieve or whether we should grieve but how can we ever justifiably stop grieving”

Source

295 - Philosophy And The Good Life— Making Sense with Sam Harris
Created: 6/14/2026, 2:54:42 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...