normative

Be Humble Extrapolating Theories Beyond Tested Regimes

We should be more humble about extrapolating established physics into untested regimes: extrapolations to black holes are very likely fine because nothing breaks down except in identifiable ways, but extrapolations to the very early universe (inflation, baryogenesis) are far less trustworthy because they rely not on robust features of quantum field theory but on specific features of specific quantum field theories — in which Carroll has little faith when pushed to the early universe; the domain of applicability of a theory is a question both physicists and philosophers should think harder about.

normativepending

Speaker

Sean Carroll

Evidence Quote

“the physics that we currently established is so good, that we do become a little complacent about extrapolating it into regimes that we haven't explicitly tested yet, and we should be a little bit more humble about that.”

Source

AMA | July 2021— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:22:53 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...