factual
Relativized Reference Class as Third Option
A possible third route between self-sampling and self-indication is to treat yourself as a random sample only from a narrower reference class of relevantly similar observers (excluding, say, post-humans who know they survived the 21st century), with different observers using different reference classes, potentially blocking both the Doomsday and presumptuous-philosopher conclusions.
factualpending
Speaker
Nick BostromEvidence Quote
“I explored the possibility of whether you could relativize the reference class, so that different observers should use different reference classes... it might then be possible to avoid both the counterintuitive implications like the Doomsday argument and the ones like the presumptuous philosophers.”
Source
111 | Nick Bostrom on Anthropic Selection and Living in a Simulation— Sean Carroll's MindscapeCreated: 6/13/2026, 12:21:43 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...