normative
Bad explanations explain anything
The defining vice of a bad explanation is that it can explain anything—like solipsism or 'the patient could be lying'—and such explanations must be excluded because they short-circuit any approach to truth; this criterion has a transcendent compellingness without being an arbitrary axiom, since rejecting it lands one in self-defeating positions like denying that mountains exist.
normativepending
Speaker
David DeutschEvidence Quote
“we're going to exclude solipsism because solipsism could explain anything... You also exclude that, because that is always true and would always short circuit any kind of trying to approach the truth”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:24:02 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...