factual

Boltzmann Brains: fruitfulness vs cognitive instability

Carroll's argument against Boltzmann Brains rests on 'cognitive instability' (citing Albert's 'Time and Chance'), but since the term doesn't directly appear in Albert's book and Albert instead defends the Past Hypothesis on grounds of its empirical fruitfulness, the questioner asks why not reject Boltzmann Brains based on the fruitfulness of the Past Axiom, which better matches Kuhnian criteria of theory choice.

factualpending

Speaker

Nick Gall

Evidence Quote

“why not base it on the *fruitfulness* of the Past Axiom instead, since the concept of fruitfulness better matches the criteria of theory choice as discussed by Kuhn and others?”

Source

AMA | May 2023— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:26:04 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...