causal
No-blemish promotion culture punishes risk-taking
The US Army's one-strike-and-you're-out, no-blemish promotion habit prevents officers who got scuffed up from rising, so high ranks fill with people who never had blemishes—meaning they may have taken too few risks and lived too conservatively—whereas in WWII relieved division commanders were given second commands and often succeeded, making the no-blemish norm a real negative for the officer corps.
causalpending
Speaker
Stanley McChrystalEvidence Quote
“If we go back to the Second World War, a number of officers were given command of infantry divisions... they got relieved of command because they didn’t do very well. Then they got put in command of another division, and in many cases, they did very well.”
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:28:06 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...