factual

Self-Consistency Proofs Are Untrustworthy

A theory proving its own consistency gives no real reason to believe it is consistent, because even an inconsistent theory would prove its own consistency—like a used car salesman telling you he is trustworthy, the statement provides no logical grounds for trust.

factualpending

Speaker

Joel David Hamkins

Evidence Quote

“It's like the used car salesman telling you, 'Oh, I'm trustworthy.' I mean, it's not a reason to trust the used car salesman, is it? Just because he says that. So similarly, if you have a theory that proves its own consistency... even an inconsistent theory would prove its own consistency.”

Source

Joel David Hamkins— Lex Fridman Podcast
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:33:58 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...