normative

Editors Identify Problems But Not Solutions

Good writing instructors and editors are almost always right when they identify that a sentence, plot twist, or piece of character development isn't working, but the solutions they offer aren't necessarily right; the best instructors isolate the structural problem and then step back to let the writer generate an organic solution, because a fix imposed in someone else's voice distorts what the author was trying to say.

normativepending

Speaker

Rebecca F. Kuang

Evidence Quote

“When editors point out flaws in a manuscript, they’re almost always right about the problem — a point of data that says this sentence, this plot twist, this piece of character development is not sticking, not resonating. But the solutions they offer aren’t necessarily the right ones.”

Source

Rebecca F. Kuang— Conversations with Tyler
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:20:00 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...