factual

Identity Over Time Is Emergent Pattern, Not Atoms

The ship of Theseus thought experiment shows that continuity of identity over time is a macroscopic, approximate, emergent notion rather than fundamental: identity inheres in the persistence of a pattern over time, not in the specific atoms, which is why people remain themselves despite atomic replacement, and why questions like 'which is the real one' after duplication (Parfit's teletransporter, or many-worlds branching) have the answer 'neither — both are continuous with the original pattern.'

factualpending

Speaker

Sean Carroll

Evidence Quote

“we should give up on treating identity over time as some fundamental feature of the universe, 'cause it's just not.”

Source

AMA | June 2021— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:37:16 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...