factual

The hockey stick was based on flawed data

The hockey-stick temperature reconstruction was misleading on two counts: it relied heavily on bristlecone pine tree rings whose width was known to reflect overgrazing-induced bark-wound growth rather than temperature, and a 'short-centering' statistical method exaggerated any 20th-century-uptick series over a hundredfold; removing the bristlecone pines and one Gaspe Peninsula series makes the hockey stick disappear, as the scientists themselves found in a file labeled 'Censored'.

factualpending

Speaker

Matt Ridley

Evidence Quote

“if you leave the bristlecone pines out, and one other paper from the Gaspe Peninsula in Canada... if you do that the hockey stick disappears altogether.”

Source

Matt Ridley on Climate Change— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:20:29 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...