causal

No Theory of Star Formation Limits Conclusions

Because we have no theory of how stars form and base all star-formation knowledge on the present-day Milky Way and nearby galaxies, extrapolating that knowledge back to a hundred million years after the Big Bang is dangerous, so apparently anomalous early JWST galaxies should not be taken as radically new physics until standard explanations are fully tested with much more data.

causalpending

Speaker

Joseph Silk

Evidence Quote

“we do not have a theory of how stars form... to extrapolate that from our current vista point of 10 billion years after the Big Bang back to near the beginning a hundred million years after, is a really dangerous and toxic thing to do.”

Source

243 | Joseph Silk on Science on the Moon— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:24:54 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...