causal

Social Services Buy Loyalty and Deter Defection

Violent entrepreneurs provide social services—roads, schools, hospitals—not mainly for ego but because doing so creates a club good that increases loyalty and deters defection, and the ability to engage in high-value illicit activity is a direct function of the ability to deter defection.

causalpending

Speaker

Gary Shiffman

Evidence Quote

“your ability to engage in high-value illicit activities is as a function of your ability to deter defection. If you cannot deter defection, you cannot engage in high-value criminal activity.”

Source

Gary Shiffman on the Economics of Violence— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:05:42 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...