causal

Consciousness Is an Organic Biochemical Phenomenon

All empirical evidence suggests consciousness is an organic, biophysical phenomenon tied to a specific carbon chemistry, physics, and electrical-chemical nerve-cell communication—every single instance of consciousness ever observed is associated with human-like animals—so just as rust requires iron and oxidation and apples require apple-tree biochemistry, consciousness appears to be a chemical property, not an abstract one that could be reproduced in software.

causalpending

Speaker

David Gelernter

Evidence Quote

“If you ask us to list instances of rusty things that have no iron content and weren't exposed to a certain kind of oxidation, the examples are zero... Nor is there a single instance of anything being conscious or having feelings that is not a human being or an animal very similar to human beings”

Source

David Gelernter on Consciousness, Computers, and the Tides of Mind— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:23:59 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...