causal

Consistency claims are arithmetic claims

Taking an objective stand on what is consistent with what commits you to objectivity about arithmetic, because consistency claims just are arithmetic claims — that set theory is consistent means there is no natural number coding a proof of '0=1' from its axioms — and by Gödel's second incompleteness theorem, if standard arithmetic is consistent then so is arithmetic conjoined with the claim that it is inconsistent, so one cannot say 'let a thousand flowers bloom, any axioms are as good as any other' while still holding there are facts about consistency.

causalpending

Speaker

Justin Clarke-Doane

Evidence Quote

“if you want to take a stand on the consistency of theories, then you're already taking a stand on arithmetic”

Source

137 | Justin Clarke-Doane on Mathematics, Morality, Objectivity, and Reality— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:21:37 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...