causal

A model disciplines a forecaster better than intuition

A forecaster is probably no better than the average pundit unless they have a model: building a statistical model commits you to rules and forces you to specify in advance things like at what point early polls become predictive, so doing your thinking ahead of time and setting up rules of evidence has a powerful disciplining effect—and his own informal low-probability call on Trump might have been improved by even a fairly bad formal model.

causalpending

Speaker

Nate Silver

Evidence Quote

“It pins you down and says, “Well, OK, early polls aren’t predictive, but at what point do they become more predictive?” ... To have an answer that is set up by an algorithm you designed ahead of time is actually maybe more helpful than people would think.”

Source

Nate Silver— Conversations with Tyler
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:26:09 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...